It finally happened to me, in a three star review I was called a scalper for selling Pokemon for more than the MSRP. Let's take a look at this:
1. How dare you. Is the term scalper not offensive? Have sports teams not changed their names for less offensive references? Maybe come up with a different term that doesn't involve a Native American stereotype. I'm not offended, but it's curious.
2. Scalper is a specific term with a legal meaning. Alright, so it's in the lexicon. Scalping is legally defined, in some jurisdictions (not mine), as buying tickets at a low price and selling them for a higher price. There are laws specifically regulating this ticket selling practice, down to how many feet from a sports venue you can sell tickets. Note that I do not sell tickets.
There is is the incorrect assumption that buying product low and selling high, over the suggested price, which they refer to as "scalping," is somehow illegal. I kid you not. There are times when someone calling you a scalper thinks they are accusing you of a crime. Just to be clear, buying low and selling high is known as commerce. There is no law or practice that limits the price we can sell goods or services, except for very specific circumstances. There is nobody to report us to, no repercussions from manufacturers, and honestly no long term hate from most customers who understand what's happening.
3. The collectible mindset. Collectible infers that the cards go up in value. You are familiar with buying low and selling high, because you expect to buy low from me and sell high to others, or at least hold those high value cards over time and peer at them through plastic. It becomes infuriating for collectors when retailers sell high. We are eating into your margin, your future value. I tell people to just wait for prices to come down, but they have strong FOMO, Fear of Missing Out. Since in their mind, values only go up.
Anyway, I buy role playing books, and if my books suddenly spiked 50% in value, I would wait for them to come down in price. I will buy the book later, or I'll buy a used copy, or a PDF. That's my suggestion, just wait. But Pokemon players look at me like I must be insane. That's because they don't believe that product can ever go down in value, only up, and it's going up all the time! The collectors mind set is this product is an in "investment," while I buy a book until I don't need it, and then dump it. I am not a collector, I am a player. We need fewer collectors and more players.
4. This whole house of cards. It should be mentioned that for a lot of stores, higher than market prices on Pokemon, which normally has the worst margin in the game trade, are keeping their stores open, driving expansion, and leading to profit margins never experienced before. When I look at my accounting, it just seems wrong. The margins are all off. If it makes you feel any better, the ecosystem survived and prospered over the last year thanks to Pokemon. More game stores are popping up every day. I know, you don't feel any better.
5. How much should we sell Pokemon for? It's simple supply and demand, with some market guidance. This year, it wasn't unusual to see our Pokemon supply last one week, while still selling well above the MSRP. There were no re-supplies coming for a lot of this product. What I would like to see is product last several months until the next set. The fact it sold out in one week means I sold it for too little, based on my stated desire for a longer shelf time. Again, it's my decision to adjust the sales velocity using price as the mechanism.
I try to keep Pokemon at a reasonable market price, using TCGPlayer as my guide. At the same time, there's nothing keeping me from deciding I want this product to last three months, or a year, or forever, because I think it's pretty, and coming up with an astronomical price to make it last. I've had a suit of armor for sale for 17 years because I think it's cool. If I sold it, I would just buy another one, so the price is high.
6. Think of the children! We have held some product back for our events, which are mostly attended by kids, but my best advice for kids right now is play electronically until this market cools down. My son has switched from Pokemon to collecting stuffies and Hot Wheels. Prices will eventually drop. Which is happening right about ... now.
7. Prices are dropping. The music stopped and retailers are sitting on a lot of Fusion Strike. Boxes sit at $117 (with an MSRP of $145, as a reminder, the price of all booster boxes when not being devalued or demand spiked). Chilling Reign, which we have a ton of, is at $98. Other retailers are trying to offload cases and pallets of overstock. Is this the end of the boom? Probably, maybe, I don't know. We're still selling a ton of product at a lower price, so demand remains while supply has improved.